[PnP] noob questions part V - bride of son of uncle of noob questions...

[Scott M]

Yeah - you would pretty much need to make a chart which would slow down combat.

Something like Leather takes -1 dmg vs. bludgeoning but +1 vs.
piercing/slashing.

Probably the opposite for plate.

But you'd still need an entry for each type of armor. More realistic
but more time consuming too.

I can live with all armors being treated the same, but losing leather
or quilted after three hits (possibly just one if 6pts or more damage
is applied) just seems really harsh.

On 11/12/07, Scott Adams <longshot at darktech.org> wrote:
>
> >1) armor and one-shot breakage. is it just me, or does everyone on the
> >planet go through an insane amount of leather and quilted armor?
> >pretty much, by the third hit from anything - chances are, it is
> >destroyed. i love breaking armor - but i thought leather would be a
> >little sturdier than that. anybody do anything special here? or should
> >pcs just plan to buy stock in the tanning industry.
> I think the system as it is now is fine.  Realistic when you deal with the material and how easy it is to shred.
> If I had to I'd come up with varying damage based on STYLE of attack.
> A thrust common sense does a small hole.  Slash does a wide but thin cut.  A wild swing could do either.  A stab..etc..
>
> So a thrust might do less damage than a slash since slash shreds more material.  Something like that.  But coming up with the rules would be a bit of time to do :).
>
> As to stock some folks do make their own armor from leather found from hunting and the ye ol Tanner skill.  So that helps but making more expensive armor is well ...expensive..material wise..
>
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> pnp mailing list
> pnp at abroere.xs4all.nl
> http://abroere.xs4all.nl/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/pnp
>